How do the FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery services compare?
FirstSearch: Precise, full-featured searching of WorldCat required by library staff and expert users
WorldCat Discovery: Discovery service that lets people search the electronic, digital, and physical resources in library collections through a single search of WorldCat and a central index of thousands of e-content collections
BOTH meet users where they start their research by increasing visibility of library collections on popular websites.
WorldShare® Management Services user interface
|Searches WorldCat + former FirstSearch Base Package databases||Searches WorldCat + central index of 2,510 e-content collections + > 200 million article records in WorldCat.org|
|Displays all library holdings from WorldCat||Displays all library holdings from WorldCat|
|Enables use of precision search features required by library staff and experienced searchers||Enables use of a single search box preferred by many users; searchers may select Advanced Search|
|Displays “unclustered” view of editions and formats||“Clusters” editions and formats in search results|
|Complements, but does not replace, a library’s existing discovery service||Includes access to precision search features in the FirstSearch interface|
How should I decide which service best meets the needs of my library and our users?
A FirstSearch/WorldCat Discovery subscription currently provides access to the FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery interfaces. As you consider your use of these services, think about your users’ needs.
- Choose FirstSearch if the primary need is for specific, precise searching of WorldCat.
- Choose WorldCat Discovery to provide users with single-search access to your library’s resources, including licensed content collections.
|Use FirstSearch if...||Use WorldCat Discovery if...|
|You want to provide precise, full-featured searching of WorldCat for library staff and library users.||You want to give users single-search access to your library’s electronic, digital, and physical collections, including materials represented in WorldCat and e-content collections you provide. This includes current WorldCat Local subscribers.|
|Your library already has a discovery service and you want to provide searching of WorldCat as a complement to that service.||You wish to use WorldCat Discovery as your library’s discovery service or as the user-facing interface to WorldShare Management Services.|
|Your users need to quickly see which libraries own materials not available in your collections.||Your users primarily want to see what is in your library’s collections.|
My library searches WorldCat at no charge through WorldCat.org™. Why should I subscribe to FirstSearch or WorldCat Discovery?
FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery provide access to more content and functionality than WorldCat.org.
|Content searched||WorldCat + more than 200 million article-level records (includes some former Base Package databases)||WorldCat + former Base Package databases||Everything in WorldCat.org + central index of 2,510 e-content collections|
|Library holdings display||Holdings of libraries with cataloging and FirstSearch/WorldCat Discovery subscriptions||All holdings in WorldCat||All holdings in WorldCat
|Search experience||Single search box + Advanced Search||Precision search features w/ detailed results||Single search box + Advanced Search|
|Interface adapts to user devices||No||No
|New search algorithm w/ more relevant results||No||No||Yes, with ongoing enhancements|
|Access to online full text||Link to local resolver||Link to local resolver||Integrated OpenURL resolver via WorldCat knowledge base or link to local resolver|
|No-charge use of CONTENTdm® “quick start”||No||No||Yes|
|WorldCat Search API||No||Yes||Yes|
|WorldCat Discovery API (in beta)||No||No||Yes|
|Display MARC record||No||No||Yes (for library staff)|
|Display OCLC symbols||No||Yes||Yes (for library staff)|
|Display OCLC record numbers||Yes||Yes||Yes (for library staff)|
Which service will new subscribers receive when they purchase a FirstSearch/WorldCat Discovery subscription today?
Current FirstSearch/WorldCat Discovery subscriptions provide access to the FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery interfaces (without features previously sold separately as WorldCat Discovery options).
What is included in the next renewal of my subscription?
Your subscription includes the following:
- FirstSearch/WorldCat Discovery subscription: Use of FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery interfaces
- FirstSearch/WorldCat Discovery + previously purchased options: Use of FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery interfaces with options purchased during the initial release of WorldCat Discovery
- WorldCat Discovery (premium): Use of FirstSearch plus WorldCat Discovery with all options previously sold as additional subscriptions (item location and real-time availability, group views, remote database search, and course reserves/reading lists)
All of these subscriptions give your collections increased visibility on search engines and popular websites, such as Goodreads and Wikipedia, when your library uses an OCLC Cataloging and Metadata Subscription to represent its collections in WorldCat.
If you want to subscribe to WorldCat Discovery (premium), you may take advantage of a promotional price that will be available through June 30, 2018. Contact email@example.com for subscription details.
What kind of group pricing is available for FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery, and when will this information be shared with groups?
Your OCLC Library Services Consultant provides custom pricing for your group that reflects your composition and needs.
My library group shares a subscription to WorldCat Discovery and has a group catalog. Is our group catalog available in WorldCat Discovery and FirstSearch?
Yes, group catalogs are available in both FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery.
Are former Base Package databases individually searchable in FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery?
All former Base Package databases remain individually searchable in FirstSearch. These include: ArchiveGrid, ArticleFirst, CAMIO, Clase & Periόdica, Electronic Books, Electronic Collections Online, ERIC, GPO Monthly Catalog, MEDLINE, OAIster, PapersFirst, ProceedingsFirst, and WorldCat Dissertations and Theses.
In WorldCat Discovery, all former Base Package databases except Clase & Periόdica are individually searchable.
How can users find my library’s e-books in FirstSearch and in WorldCat Discovery?
FirstSearch searches the WorldCat database, so if your e-book holdings are represented in WorldCat, they are included in search results.
The Ebook database of e-book records from WorldCat is also searchable in FirstSearch and WorldCat Discovery.
WorldCat Discovery provides access to more than 20 million e-books discoverable through WorldCat plus a central index of 2,510 e-content collections. Many of the collections in the central index include metadata for e-books. When your library’s e-books holdings are present in the WorldCat knowledge base, users can link directly to the e-books from search results.
NOTE: WorldShare Collection Manager streamlines maintenance of your e-book holdings in the WorldCat knowledge base.
My library uses WorldCat Local, and we plan to begin using WorldCat Discovery when it contains the features we need. What features will be added to WorldCat Discovery next?
Areas of focus for near-term enhancements include the following:
- Search experience
- Researching, defining, and testing next version of relevance algorithms
- Streamlined academic research
- Report a broken link
- View all full text links on search results
- Place hold and shelving notes
- Choose navigation bar color
Consult the WorldCat Discovery Community Center for WorldCat Discovery enhancement plans.
Will my WorldCat Local subscription price change when my library transitions to WorldCat Discovery?
No, your WorldCat Local subscription price will not change. The subscription continues to support use of WorldCat Discovery (premium), which includes all features previously sold separately as options.
When should my WorldCat Local library move to WorldCat Discovery?
Many WorldCat Local subscribers have completed their implementation of WorldCat Discovery. Others plan to transition when the service offers features important to them.
This is a good time to look at WorldCat Discovery and familiarize yourself with the interface in preparation for your move to the service. Guidance for your transition is provided in Configuration for WorldCat Local libraries moving to WorldCat Discovery.
If you have not already done so, request your library’s unique WorldCat Discovery URL.
Will FirstSearch maintain the functionality that exists in the current service?
FirstSearch will continue to provide the precision search features users have told us they rely on. We will continue to solicit input from members through focus groups, individual library consultations, and requests submitted via OCLC Customer Support and the OCLC Community Center. A FirstSearch Advisory Group is also assisting with plans for FirstSearch.
What is the timeframe for releasing the WorldCat Discovery API (in beta) for broader use?
We are assessing the readiness of the WorldCat Discovery API for broader use by WorldCat Discovery subscribers based on feedback we received from users during the current beta. Once the assessment is complete, we will provide an update on broader use of this API.
FirstSearch is the most powerful interface for searching WorldCat. Researchers and library staff can find and select resources in thousands of library collections with rich information from WorldCat records. FirstSearch libraries are also more visible on the popular websites where people often begin their research.
FirstSearch reference service