Part 2: Widening the library's circle of influence

By Tom Storey
In the last issue of NextSpace, we looked
at how libraries can extend their reach
beyond traditional boundaries in order to
better reach users in new and compelling
ways. In this issue, we’ll continue to
focus on this “ripple effect,” but from the
standpoint of how libraries can generate
enthusiasm and action within the
communities that support them.
Connecting with users is, of course,
essential to the mission of libraries.
But building civic, commercial and
governmental support is key to the
survival of libraries. The ripple effect
needs to come full circle, touching
everyone who is involved in the success
of libraries and helping to show the links
between support and service.
Advocacy as a lifestyle choice
Gerry Meek walked into the Grand
Ballroom at the Chicago Hilton for the
advocacy discussion. He sat down and
introduced himself to the few librarians
already seated around the table. Then he looked at
the empty chairs.
Later recalling that meeting at ALA Annual, he
asked the question, “Why wasn’t that table full?
Advocacy and community building are the most
important things we do.”
 |
| “I want a porous organization that is out in the community and sees the possible in every situation in order for us to extend our reach and create new partnerships.” |
Gerry makes sure that advocacy is a lifestyle, not
just a series of programs, at the Calgary Public Library in Alberta, Canada. As Chief Executive Officer, he
weaves the theme of advocacy into everything he
and his staff do and into every community connection
they make. Advocacy “Meek-style” is a management
philosophy and a service philosophy all in one. You
should, though, forget any idea that an advocacy
lifestyle is preachy and self-important. With Gerry, it
has to be full of energy, adventure, laughter and a
sense of fun in order to succeed.
Gerry’s commitment to advocacy begins with whom
he hires. By his estimate, 80 percent of librarians are
introverts, 20 percent extroverts. He has filled his
staff with people from that 20 percent, he claims! “I’m
trying to run the circus from the monkey’s cage,” he
laughs. “I hire only people who smile, because one of
my metrics is the smiles we create—smiles per hour.”
He puts all new employees through an
orientation boot camp during which he
emphasizes the library’s ABCs—Always
Be Connecting—and everyone’s role in
advocacy. He hands out ‘blue sky’ notebooks
that he tells staff to take into the community
to record ‘wicked, innovative new ideas’ as
well as ways to bring ‘flash to the obvious.’
Then he checks up on them.
“I want a porous, sponge-like organization
that is out in the community and sees the
possible in every situation in order for
us to extend our reach and create new
partnerships. I tell staff to listen, reflect, act.
Start with who you know in the community.
What service clubs are you are a part of,
what cultural organizations do you belong to.
I tell them I have ‘creation funds’ from which
we can run pilots for things libraries might
not traditionally do.”
Does it work? Before we get to Gerry’s
results, let’s take the “ripple effect” to
this topic, as well, and widen the circle of
examples beyond the library profession.
What can we learn from observing how
other community organizations utilize their
connections to succeed.
The four Ps of successful advocacy:
Passion, Planning, Partnerships, Promotion
It was the dream of making society work better together
that led Michael Brown and Alan Khazei to start City Year, a
national youth service organization founded in 1988. Fresh out
of Harvard Law School, both turned down prestigious job offers
in order to follow their passion for creating a nonprofit venture
that they hoped would engage youth to change the world.
 |
| Co-Founder and Chief Executive Officer Michael Brown says City Year is experiential.
“We ask people to come for a visit to experience what we are doing.”
(Photo by Andrew Dean) |
Today, 21 years later, they have succeeded not only in
building a high-impact organization, but also in playing an
influential role in advocating for a national service policy in the
United States.
Corps members serve as tutors, mentors, role models and
leaders of after-school programs to help students and schools
succeed. They also transform their communities through
physical services, such as:
- painting murals
- planting gardens
- creating play spaces
- renovating schools, and
- refurbishing community centers.
From a small, 50-person pilot program in its initial year,
City Year has grown to 20 locations across the country and in
South Africa. Since its inception, City Year has:
- graduated more than 12,500 alumni
- served 1.1 million children
- completed more than 20 million hours of service, and
- engaged more than 1.05 million citizens in service.
For the 1988 pilot, Michael and Alan raised the $200,000
they needed from four corporate sponsors. In 2009, City
Year has revenues of $58 million, of which about half come
from contributions and private grants. It has more than
350 corporate sponsors, including local companies in the
20 locations where it operates. And about a quarter of its
revenues come from federal grants.
What made City Year succeed? How did it identify who to
approach for sponsorship and get on their radar screen to
make a pitch? How was it able to win the trust of its major
supporters for ongoing funding? And how did it leverage its
initial success to advocate policy changes and expand into the
political sphere for government funding?
Passion. Both Michael and Alan had a deep-rooted belief that their
idea could change the world and they both had an exuberant, energetic,
unyielding spirit to make it happen. They wanted to transform the lives of
people in the communities they served as well as City Year volunteers,
making them all better citizens. And they wanted City Year to be the
model for public service program design and an institution that lasts way
beyond themselves.
“We fancied ourselves as social entrepreneurs and like to say we built a
national service organization out of our garage,” Michael remembers. “We
were inspired by Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak (Apple Inc.), and
also by Peter Ueberroff (former baseball commissioner), who really put
corporate sponsorship all together as the architect of the 1984 Olympics.
We figured if he could get a corporation to sponsor a volleyball team, we
could get one to sponsor a team of youth for community service.”
Planning. Michael remembers that it was the City Year concept that
first attracted the attention of his initial donors. But it was their detailed,
business-like plan—complete with a long-term vision, budget numbers,
recruiting methods, work hours and achievable goals—that brought the
Bank of Boston (now the Bank of America), The Equitable, General
Cinema, and Bain & Company on board.
“Getting that first meeting was very, very hard,” says Michael. “We had
to knock on a lot of doors and rely on people who knew people who knew
people who knew people. But we were very determined. Eventually, we met
someone who knew the person in charge of giving at what was then the
Bank of Boston. They liked our idea and became a sponsor. Once they did,
frankly, it became easier to attract other major sponsors.”
The ripple effect at work again.
Partnerships. From the start, Michael and Alan found ways to ensure
that their sponsors benefitted from their partnership with City Year. Their
belief that businesses have civic responsibilities and that City Year could
help them “do well while doing good” was important, but it also was
key to take a company’s interests into consideration and to connect to
its corporate goals and strategies, rather than simply being a recipient
of a grant.
“I get asked a lot about how you get money from corporations,” Michael
says. “That’s not the right kind of perspective. You need to be fully
knowledgeable about the company and know everything you can about their
giving strategy and philanthropy efforts. Then you need to ask them about
how you can help them do more to meet their goals and objectives.”
“Corporations want to express their idealism. Bain & Company has been
one of our sponsors for each of our 21 years. City Year is a way for them
to express their civic values and engage themselves and their employees
both personally and professionally. City Year youth are ambassadors for
their company both internally and externally. They wear the company name
on their jackets while doing their community service and go back into
the company to tell about the good things they are doing, which makes
employees feel very good about their company.”
Promotion. Once Michael and Alan got their program established and
successful, word spread and attention increased. And they were able to
leverage their success into additional sponsorships, expansion into other
cities and adopting policy advocacy as a means for obtaining federal
funds and influencing larger policy decisions.
“Our private strategy was very helpful
to our public strategy,” Michael says. “We
founded City Year at a time when the idea
of public/private partnerships was coming to
the forefront, but most started out the other
way—public to private. That sometimes makes
it hard for the private sector to see how they
fit in. We had always planned on engaging
the public sector, and we leveraged our
relationships in the private sector to get into
the public sector. Government could see that
our model was already working and that it
already had the support of the private sector.
We could demonstrate our success.”
In 1992, City Year invited all U.S. presidential
candidates to learn about its mission. Then
Governor Bill Clinton spent two hours with
City Year talking not only with City Year youth
but also sponsors, one of whom was Bain & Company Chairman Mitt Romney, who
talked about how successful the company’s
partnership with City Year was. President
Clinton has said on many occasions that
City Year was an inspiration for AmeriCorps,
which now funds 800 organizations and where
City Year gets about a quarter of its funding.
In the end, Michael says, it’s all about
developing strategic partnerships and
sharing the joint space of community service. “Connecting the nonprofit space with the
corporate space with the government space
provides a nonpartisan way for everyone to
come together and be part of a solution that
demonstrates the power of service.”
Translating ideas into action, and
action into results
Gerry Meek’s philosophy—and the buy-in
from his staff and administration—drive the
processes and programs in Calgary that
seek to engage outside organizations in the
success of the library. Gerry makes sure that his
staffers are building influence in the community
through constant contact and interaction with
community and business leaders.
Every branch manager keeps a Rolodex file with
detailed information on 25 key stakeholders in their
district. Programs they’ve launched with the help of
other local groups include:
- It’s a crime not to read. The library partnered
with the police department to encourage literacy and
grow library awareness. Once a month, a librarian
and a police officer visit students in second and
third grade. The officer reads from a book selected
by the library and encourages kids to set personal
reading goals. Library staff got the police department
to participate by convincing them that reading and
literacy are crime-prevention tools. “Just look at the
illiteracy in prisons,” Gerry says. The program also
provides a favorable image of police to the community,
he says. Originally piloted in one school, the program
now takes place in eight schools, involves staff from
six library branches and police officers from five
districts. Six Calgary Rotary Clubs and one corporate
sponsor supply the $20,000 funding.
The Original Recycler. This program promotes
the Calgary Public Library as the original “recycler”–sharing library materials reduces the amount of paper
produced and, ultimately, discarded. In 2008, the
library enhanced its environmental efforts with two
special initiatives:
- “Green Before Green Was Cool.” This was
a special media event during Environment Week
to promote that being green is as simple as using
the Calgary Public Library. Costumed characters
showed how library cardholders saved paper,
water and air environment simply by borrowing
books instead of buying them.
- Special library cards, which could be planted.
Just as a real library card helps grow the mind, the special
seeded cards printed on biodegradable, recycled paper
grew wildflowers to help the environment.
The library also runs a breakfast leadership institute to
raise its profile and get closer to the leadership of the
community. The Institute brings in the mayor, the chamber
of commerce president and other VIPs to talk about their
leadership journeys to library staff. “It’s a chance for them
to tell their stories and for us to provide information about
the library and get exposure to community leadership. I
tell my staff that we need to link to the emerging agenda
in the community.”
The library board is also engaged and involved
personally with advocating the library to the
community through speeches, presentations
and appearances. To support this effort, Gerry
and his staff maintain a ‘story bank’ of user
testimonials that they supply to board members
for use in their efforts. The story might be a
grandfather who learned to read to his grandchild
or an immigrant family that relied on the support
of the library. No matter the topic, though, the
stories are ready-made ways for board members
to illustrate the personal difference the library
has made in people’s lives.
You can see the ripples spreading out into the
community. From Gerry’s philosophy to staffing
decisions and procedure requirements … to
the library board … to other civic and business
organizations. As often as possible, in as many
places as possible, the Calgary library is seen as a
player and partner, fundamental to the success of
the community.
The Ripple Effect in the
academic setting
Perhaps one of the masters at building influence
and support is E. Gordon Gee, President of The
Ohio State University and recently named Time magazine’s top college president. Throughout
his three-decade career as president at West
Virginia University, University of Colorado,
Brown University, Vanderbilt University and
Ohio State, Gordon has demonstrated a skill at
forming coalitions and drumming up support for
education funding from various constituencies—businesses, alumni, legislators and local residents
to name a few.
Among his latest achievements:
- His relentless advocacy for the transforming
power of education was key to keeping
higher education funding largely stable in
Ohio’s 2010/11 state budget, despite deep
cuts in most every other program.
- During his seven-year tenure as Chancellor
at Vanderbilt, he raised more than $1.25
billion by building new partnerships
with parents, friends, patients, alumni,
foundations, corporations and the medical
community. More than 745,000 gifts from
174,200 supporters were received as part
of the Shape the Future campaign. Gordon
also increased the quality of incoming
students as measured by SAT scores, and
Vanderbilt also moved up the rankings of
America’s best colleges.
Gordon is also a strong advocate for libraries, having
authored two books on the strategic importance of libraries
in student learning. And he has strengthened library
services at each of the institutions where he has served
as president. At a September 2009 dedication of the
Thompson Library at Ohio State, following a $100 million
makeover, he spoke about how the library is the soul of the
university and of the ways in which rich history and tradition
combine with advancement and modernization at the newly
renovated library.
The new library is symbolic of the reform that Gordon
seeks in higher education.
“Libraries are transformational places, as central to
our shared future as they have been to our past,” he told
NextSpace. “Yet, the needs of the 21st century demand that
those of us who serve the public good shed old habits and
mindsets. No longer can we quietly conduct our business
and expect others to provide us with necessary resources. It
is imperative that we expand programs in our communities,
aggressively and creatively partnering with all kinds of
organizations. Now more than ever, we make our case for
investment in our institutions by the moral force of our work.”
Passion, planning, partnership and promotion are at the
heart of academic library success, too, it seems.
The fifth P? Payoff
Gerry Meek’s advocacy philosophy for the Calgary Public
Library has clearly been successful, based on the hardest,
most realistic measure possible—funding. Between 2006 and
2008, revenues increased 20 percent, from $37 million to
$44.5 million. Funding for three new branches was approved.
And plans for a new central library are in the works, with the
site and land already secured.
At the heart of Gerry’s advocacy and community building
is his desire to create and instill a deeper sense of purpose
in his organization.
“We’re a recession sanctuary and a thinking space. We’re
a social utility and community deficit fighter against poverty
and illiteracy. We serve our community with both passion
and compassion. We’re also cheap and easy. There’s no
sticker shock.”
He continues, “We need to be recognized as a community
action center, a place where hope and optimism is possible.
That requires a discernible style that’s distinctively ours, a new
vocabulary, and new metaphors to describe our fundamental
role as a place offering access to both record and insight.”
President’s Report | Libraries, archives and museums find more in common—together
|